Posts

Creative Problem Solving: The Art of Thinking Sideways When Everyone Else Goes Straight

Three weeks ago, I watched a room full of supposedly brilliant executives spend forty-seven minutes debating whether to use blue or green folders for their quarterly reports. Meanwhile, their biggest competitor had just launched a product that made their entire business model look like a horse and cart in a Tesla showroom.

That's the thing about creative problem solving - most people think it's about brainstorming sessions with sticky notes and those awful trust-fall exercises. They couldn't be more wrong. Real creative problem solving is about developing the mental agility to see problems from angles that would make a contortionist jealous.

After fifteen years of watching businesses trip over the same obstacles repeatedly, I've come to believe that the biggest problem with problem solving isn't the problems themselves. It's that we've been trained to think in straight lines when life comes at us in spirals, loop-de-loops, and occasionally backwards through a funhouse mirror.

The Straight-Line Trap

Here's what drives me mental: walk into any corporate training room and they'll show you the "traditional problem-solving process." Step one, identify the problem. Step two, gather information. Step three, generate solutions. Step four, evaluate options. Step five, implement. Step six, review.

Bollocks.

That works brilliantly if you're assembling IKEA furniture or following a recipe for pavlova. But when was the last time a real business problem came with instructions and an Allen key? Never, that's when.

I learned this the hard way back in '09 when I was consulting for a logistics company in Brisbane. They called me in because their delivery times were getting worse, customer complaints were through the roof, and their drivers were threatening to quit. Classic operational nightmare.

Following the textbook approach, I spent two weeks mapping their processes, interviewing stakeholders, and creating flowcharts that looked like abstract art. The solution seemed obvious: optimise routes, implement better tracking systems, provide customer service training.

Six months and $40,000 later, nothing had improved. Actually, it got worse.

The Sideways Solution

Then one afternoon, I'm having a coffee with Jake, one of their senior drivers. Proper old-school truckie, been doing the job for twenty-three years. I'm expecting him to complain about the new tracking system or the revised delivery schedules.

Instead, he says: "You know what the real problem is? These new housing estates don't have proper street numbers. Half the time we're driving around like headless chooks because 47A is between numbers 23 and 98, and don't get me started on those bloody unit complexes where the numbers run backwards."

Bingo.

The problem wasn't internal processes or staff training. It was that their entire city was changing faster than their systems could adapt. New developments, changed street layouts, renumbered addresses. Their drivers weren't inefficient - they were navigating a constantly shifting maze with outdated maps.

The solution? They partnered with local councils to get advance notice of address changes and development approvals. They hired a part-timer whose only job was updating their address database weekly. Cost them maybe $800 a month. Delivery times improved by 34% within six weeks.

That's creative problem solving. Not thinking outside the box - thinking like there is no box.

Why Most Creative Problem Solving Training Misses the Mark

The problem with most creative problem solving activities is they focus on techniques instead of mindset. They'll teach you about mind mapping and the six thinking hats and SCAMPER methods. All useful tools, don't get me wrong. But tools without the right mental framework are like giving someone a Ferrari when they still think they're supposed to ride horses.

Here's my controversial opinion: the best creative problem solvers I know aren't necessarily the most creative people. They're the most curious. They're the ones who ask "what if" instead of "why not." They're comfortable being wrong, looking stupid, and starting over.

Take Sarah, who runs a mid-sized accounting firm in Melbourne. Textbook logical thinker, wouldn't know creativity if it knocked on her door wearing a beret and carrying a paintbrush. But when the pandemic hit and half her clients were screaming about cash flow, she didn't just offer payment plans or fee reductions.

She pivoted to offering "business health checks" - essentially free consultations where she'd spend an hour with struggling businesses, not to sell them anything, but to help them identify what government support they qualified for and which expenses they could legitimately restructure.

Revenue from new clients increased 127% that year. Not because she got more creative with her marketing or her service offerings. Because she got curious about what her clients actually needed instead of what she was trained to provide.

The Philosophy of Productive Confusion

This might sound mental, but I reckon the secret to creative problem solving is learning to be productively confused. Most people hate confusion. It makes them uncomfortable. They want clear definitions, obvious solutions, straightforward paths from A to B.

But confusion is where the magic happens. When you don't know what you're looking at, you see everything. When you're not sure what the problem is, you consider possibilities that wouldn't occur to someone who thinks they've got it all figured out.

I remember working with a manufacturing company that was losing contracts because their quality control was apparently substandard. Classic problem, right? Improve QC processes, retrain staff, invest in better equipment.

Except when I started digging deeper, I discovered their quality control was actually better than their competitors. The real issue was that their sales team had been overselling their capabilities for months, promising delivery times and specifications they couldn't meet, then blaming "quality issues" when they inevitably came up short.

The problem wasn't quality control. It was integrity. And that's a completely different conversation.

Building Your Creative Problem Solving Muscle

If you want to get better at this stuff, start small. Next time someone complains about something - anything - don't immediately try to fix it. Instead, ask yourself: what if this isn't actually the problem they think it is?

Your mate complains their coffee machine is broken? Maybe they're actually stressed about money and the broken coffee machine is just the thing that tipped them over. Your team says they need more time to complete projects? Maybe they need clearer priorities, not more hours.

Practice looking for the problem behind the problem. Then look for the problem behind that one.

I've started doing this thing where I deliberately choose the wrong solution first. If the obvious answer is A, I'll explore B, C, and sometimes Z just to see what I learn. Usually, I end up back at A anyway, but with a much better understanding of why A is right and how it could be improved.

The Australian Advantage

Here's something I'm genuinely proud of: Australians are naturally pretty good at creative problem solving. Maybe it's because our entire history is basically "how do we make this work in a place that's trying to kill us?" Maybe it's because we've never had enough people or resources to do things the "proper" way, so we've always had to improvise.

Whatever the reason, we've got this cultural comfort with making do, having a go, and trying something different when the usual approach isn't working. The problem is, we often don't recognise this as a skill. We think it's just being resourceful or practical.

But that's exactly what creative problem solving is. It's being resourceful with your thinking, not just your materials.

The Time Factor

One thing that really gets under my skin is this idea that creative problem solving takes forever. All that brainstorming and blue-sky thinking and collaborative workshops. Sometimes, sure. But often the most creative solutions are also the fastest.

Remember my truckie friend Jake? He identified the real problem in about thirty seconds of casual conversation. The "traditional" approach had me spinning my wheels for months.

The trick is knowing when to slow down and when to speed up. Complex problems with multiple stakeholders and long-term implications? Take your time. Daily operational issues that are driving everyone mental? Sometimes the answer is staring you in the face and you just need someone to point it out.

Making It Stick

The hardest part of creative problem solving isn't coming up with creative solutions. It's getting other people to accept them. Especially in larger organisations where anything that hasn't been done before is automatically suspicious.

This is where you need to become a bit of a politician. Frame your creative solution in language that sounds familiar and safe. Don't say "I think we should try this completely different approach." Say "This builds on what we're already doing well and addresses the gaps we've identified."

Don't present it as revolutionary. Present it as evolutionary. People can handle evolution. Revolution makes them nervous.

Actually, that reminds me of something that happened last year with a client in the hospitality industry. They were losing staff faster than they could hire them, classic retention problem. Management wanted to throw money at it - higher wages, better benefits, team building events.

But when I talked to the staff who were leaving, wages weren't even in the top three complaints. They were frustrated because the roster system meant they never knew their shifts more than a week in advance, making it impossible to plan anything outside work. Social life, family time, second jobs - everything was on hold indefinitely.

The creative solution? They moved to monthly roster planning with guaranteed minimum shifts. Staff could swap shifts through an app, but everyone knew their baseline schedule four weeks out. Cost the company absolutely nothing to implement. Staff turnover dropped by 68% in three months.

See what I mean? The creative part wasn't the solution itself - roster planning isn't exactly rocket science. The creative part was looking past the obvious answers to find what people actually needed.

That's the thing about creative problem solving. It's not about being clever for the sake of being clever. It's about being useful in ways that nobody else thought to try.

The truth is, most problems aren't nearly as complicated as we make them out to be. We just get so focused on the trees that we forget we're standing in a forest. Sometimes the most creative thing you can do is take a step back, look around, and ask yourself: "What am I not seeing here?"

Usually, the answer is simpler than you think. And that's the most creative solution of all.